Today, the interesting editor of history will bring you the function of the ancient tributary system . I hope it can help everyone.
The tributary system is a unique international relationship system invented by the Chinese. It has been practiced in China for thousands of years, from the Zhou Dynasty to the Ming and Qing Dynasties.
Although there are changes in the process, in general, the central dynasty "seals rewards" to the vassal states , that is, countries such as Vietnam and North Korea, and the vassal states "call the tribute to the vassal".
This is the tributary system.
All the history books we can see are basically negative attitudes towards the tributary system, generally for two reasons:
First, when foreigners come to China, they feel that China treats other countries too unequally. Can't everyone sit down and talk well, why do you have to kneel to the Chinese emperor ? Why do I send a gift, you have to call it a "tribute" from the bottom up? Why do you have to call something back What about the "reward" from the top down? It feels like China is bullying the small ones.
Secondly, the Chinese do not understand it, and feel that the tributary system is a set of lavish gifts. It is the dynasty that protects its own face and hesitates to be the head of injustice. Tributes from abroad come with tributes, but the dynasties often give them more rewards. Therefore, it puts a lot of pressure on the Chinese government's finances, and it is hard to lose face and suffer.
If foreigners don't like this system and Chinese people don't like it, then we can't explain why the tributary system can last so long.
For thousands of years, individual emperors will inevitably have vanity, but it is difficult to imagine that the Chinese government is under tremendous financial pressure and insisted on this system for thousands of years just for the sake of vanity.
Still, can you say that the emperor is stupid, but every minister under him is stupid? You can say that an emperor and the civil and military officials of the Manchu dynasty are stupid, but so many emperors and leaders in all dynasties are stupid ?
The tributary system can exist for a long time, and each Central Plains dynasty will start after taking office, indicating that China can benefit from it.
Today we come to re-examine the tributary system and count this account again.
Let's calculate the economic account first. Is China losing money?
Tribute trade is definitely not cost-effective, because less tribute and more rewards.
But you think, trade is human instinct. How can such a large China trade with its vassal states, that is, the entire East Asian trade circle, be confined to such a small amount of trade as "tribute rewards"?
Tributary trade is important, but in terms of share, it is actually just the tip of the iceberg.
The tributary trade did suffer a little, but its role was to maintain peace in the East Asian world and then compensate it back dozens of times through other forms of trade.
In the early days of reform and opening up, Western countries assisted us, and now we assist Africa, the same reasoning. On the surface, it seems like a loss, but in fact, by doing other business, you can earn a lot.
The Pictures of the Coming Kingdoms during the Qianlong Period
Especially in southern China, in the 1830s and 1990s, during the Emperor Qianlong , trade tariffs contributed one-sixth of Fujian's provincial tax and nearly three-quarters of Guangdong's local tax revenue. This is only officially recognized trade, not including private trade.
You see, economically, the tributary system actually has more advantages than disadvantages.
OK, let's calculate the political account again.
In a broad sense, there have been two systems of international relations in the world.
One is the "tribute system" of the Chinese civilization we are talking about today; the other is the "Westphalian system".
What is this latter system?
After the brutal "Thirty Years War" in Europe ended in 1648, the participating parties signed a series of treaties. This treaty system is the Westphalian system. It establishes several principles, that is, all countries, regardless of size, are equal, respect each other's territorial sovereignty, and so on.
Today's international relations still follow these basic principles.
European countries sign peace treaties
It seems to people today that nations, regardless of size, are equal, which is perfectly logical. The tributary system is based on national inequality. It seems that it really lags behind and should be eliminated.
But if we look deeper into history, we will find that the problem is not so simple.
The main goal of an international system is to maintain peace.
But hundreds of years after the establishment of the Westphalian system, European and American wars have not stopped.
From 1300-1850, there were at least 46 wars between Britain and France; Sweden, now a well-known neutral country, also participated in 32 wars during this period.
In fact, it is rooted in the principles of the Westphalian system-equality and mutual respect for sovereignty and territory.
The so-called equality is that there is no boss, and no one is convinced.
The so-called mutual respect for sovereignty means that everyone's power boundary is clear.
If I want to take advantage of you, there is no room for trading and forbearance under the table, I can only fight directly to grab your territory.
So you see, in practice, the beautiful principle on the file often turns into a robber logic when you turn your face.
The peace treaty is in fact a piece of waste paper without the strength to back it up.
In contrast, East Asia under the contemporary tributary system started from the establishment of the Ming Dynasty in 1368 and the dissolution of the tributary system in 1841.
For almost 500 years, there have been only two wars between East Asian countries.
In 1407, China sent troops to fight against Vietnam; in 1592, Japan's Toyotomi Hideyoshi attacked North Korea, and China sent troops to protect.
In addition, long-term peace has been maintained among East Asian countries such as China, North Korea, Vietnam, and Japan.
Why is unequal international relations easy to make peace?
Because inequality means that there is a recognized authority on arbitration contradictions.
In rural China, older and prestigious elderly people will play a role in resolving contradictions in the village. Zhang San and Zhang Si caused conflicts in the fields, and the solution was either to fight each other or to find an old village chief to be fair.
Obviously, with the old village chief, the conflicts in the village will be reduced a lot, otherwise the only way for everyone to solve the problem will be fighting.
What's the problem, let the village chief come out and comment
Back to the international system.
If you measure by peacekeeping, you will find that the tributary system is much better and more effective.
The reason people advocate equality between nations is mainly concerned that if international relations are unequal, large nations will bully small nations.
But in history, not only did it not bully vassal states, but it also provided security protection.
As long as they recognize China's sovereign state and accept the book, China will not even interfere in their internal affairs, let alone have the interest to rob their territory and occupy their country.
Of course, there is no longer a tributary system in the world today, and it is impossible to restore the tributary system again. But when we observe international politics, don't forget that these two basic logics still work.
In today's international politics, the principle of equality of the Westphalian system is superficially followed.
But in essence, there are variants of the tributary system in many areas-there is a dominated country in one area, other small countries recognize its status, and it is responsible for protecting regional security and taking care of small country interests. Although there is no such thing as "tribute", but the essence is one thing.
For example, North and South America led by the United States, Oceania led by Australia, and Central Asia led by Russia.
The United States operates Latin America as its own "back garden"
There are no central states in the Middle East and Africa, so that conflicts can only be resolved by force, and peaceful development becomes extremely difficult. And even if the world ’s police intervene, it will not help. After all, your sphere of influence is not there, and your influence is limited.
When the central state of a region declines, the entire region will fall into turmoil. After the defeat of the Qing dynasty in the Opium War, all the neighboring countries became colonies , and there was no peace at all.
In the future, East and Southeast Asia will return to the "tributary system" centered on China two hundred years ago, which is the result of historical development.
Of course, this does not mean that China will bully others . From a practical point of view, recognizing the status of the elder brother in China will actually ensure peace in the entire region.
Disclaimer: The above content originates from the Internet, and the copyright belongs to the original author. If you infringe your original copyright, please let us know and we will delete the related content as soon as possible.
There are many heroes in ancient history. Have you heard the story of Yue Fei? There is a very powerful army in the Song Dynasty. Details
We all know that each dynasty's throne inheritance is very cautious and must be of pure blood. For this, the emperor details
There are many heroes in ancient history. Have you heard the story of Wei Chigong? Li Shimin can have such high achievements .
Today, the editor of Fun History brought you the Qianlong Zen position, why would n’t he give up power? I hope it can help you. Details
In history, Hou Qiaowen can be said to be very famous, so do you know his story? Next details
In history, Chai Rong can be said to be very famous, so do you know his story? Next interesting details
In the long history, Feng Dao can be said to be very famous, so do you know his story? Next interesting details
Yan Zhenqing, a historical figure, believes that everyone should be very familiar with it. Yan Zhenqing was a famous Tang dynasty and historical details.
Today, the interesting history editor brought you what Hong Xiuquan did after capturing Nanjing? Interested readers can follow the editor for details.
Do you know whether Zhu Xi believes in Buddhism or Taoism? The interesting historical editor will explain it for you. Details of the early Ming dynasty
Hello everyone, here is the interesting history editor, today I will tell you about Zhang Xianzhong's "Silver Legend" story, welcome to pay attention to details
Where did the "Five Hus" ethnic groups go during the "Five Hus"? It is a question that many people want? The following interesting history editor is for details.
Today, the interesting history editor brought you an article about ancient counsellors' tips, welcome to read ~ Many people details
Do you know Zhao Kuangyin's story? Next, the interesting history editor will explain it for you. First details of Song Taizu Zhao Kuangyin
Do you really understand the changes in Ganlu Temple? Today ’s interesting historical editor brings you a new interpretation ~ Details of the changes in Ganlu Temple
Do you know the story of Yongzheng? Next, the interesting historical editor will explain it for you. Several big details happened during the Yongzheng reign
Hello everyone, here is the interesting history editor. Today I will tell you Jia Jia's story. Welcome to pay attention. Details of this counselor
Do you really understand Huang Quan? The interesting editor of history provides you with detailed related content. Why Cao Cao insists on details
Today, the interesting editor of history brings you the true or false incident of Tang Taizong? I hope it can help you. Details
Do you know what kind of wars happened after the invasion of China? The history editor will explain it for you. Details
Today, the editor of Fun History will bring you the road of titled Bai Jue. I hope it will be helpful to everyone. Bai Qi Shi Wu Details
Today, the interesting history editor will bring you the two weirdest wars in history! I hope it will be helpful to everyone. Details
Today, the editor of Fun History will bring you the loss of the Battle of Yiling and Shuhan. AD Details
Today, the interesting history editor will bring you the specific process of the battle of Baibiguan. I hope it can help you. In the " details
Do you know why Tang Jun can fight with one enemy and four against the battle of Baijiangkou? Next, the history editor will explain it for you. Details of AD 6
Today, the interesting history editor brought you the story of the battle of Baijiangkou. Interested readers can follow the editor for details.
Today's interesting history editor brought you the battle of why Zhao She could defeat Qin Guo? I hope it can help you. Details
Do you know when the battle at the Xiangji Temple was fought? I don't know if it's okay, the interesting history editor told you. Tang Dynasty details
Hello everyone, here is the interesting history editor. Today I will tell you about the pros and cons of taking over the party in the battle of Changping. Welcome to pay attention. Details
Today, the interesting history editor brings you the analysis of the defeat of the battle of the Salars of the Ming Army. I hope it can help you. Details
There are many heroes in ancient history. Have you heard the story of Zhu Yuanzhang? Because of the tyranny of the Yuan Dynasty, people have been going through details
When mentioning Li Dan always remembers the image on TV, then the interesting history editor has to tell you the details in detail
Whenever mentioning the image of Queen Guo always on television, then the interesting history editor has to tell you the details
Whenever mentioning Du Qiuniang always remembers the image on TV, then the interesting history editor has to tell you the details
Do you know Feng Qing's story? Next, the interesting history editor will explain it for you. Feng Qing, the nephew of the Northern Wei civilization, details
Hello everyone, here is the interesting history editor. Today I will tell you about Wei Zifu's story. Welcome to pay attention. Details of grandmother sinus
Today, the interesting history editor brought you an article about the Northeast Dashidian, welcome to read ~ Dashidian is the details
How important is the ancient jade seal? The interesting historical editor will introduce the relevant content in detail for everyone. Well known, details
Today, the interesting history editor brings you how eunuchs have become popular step by step, and have brought disaster to the country and the people? I hope I can give you details
Today's interesting history editor brought you why Qin Shihuang did not artificially react when he was alive? Interested readers can follow the editor for details
Do you know the status of the "King King" of the Qing Dynasty? I don't know if it's okay, the interesting history editor told you. Details of the Qing Dynasty
Today's interesting history editor brought you the beginning of the decline of the Han Dynasty? I hope it can help you. Details
Today, the interesting history editor brings you the precocity of the political system of China and the state. Interested readers can learn more
Today, the interesting editor of history will bring you the function of the ancient tributary system. I hope it can help everyone. Details
Today ’s interesting history editor prepared for everyone: What problems will ancient Chinese “emphasis on agriculture and business suppression” bring? Details of interested guys
Today's interesting history editor brought you why the Ming emperor worshiped Wudang Mountain? Welcome to read ~ For more details
What dynasties does the interesting history editor bring to you today? There are two Beijing systems? I hope it can help you. Details in
Today, the interesting history editor brings you the long lived fox king in "Journey to the West" why can you live so long? Details of interested readers
Is Sun Wukong really a born question that many people ask? The following interesting historical editor will bring you detailed answers. Details
Today's interesting history editor brings you "Journey to the West" Why do black bear monsters like 袈裟? Interested readers can follow the details
Today, the fun history editor brings you "one day for the day, two days for the future, and three days for the crystal". What should I do? Greek details
Today, the interesting history editor will bring you what fairy magic in the Journey to the West is better than Sun Wukong? I hope to have more details for you
Today, the interesting history editor brings you the four long-lived medicines in the Journey to the West! I hope it can help you. Seen details
Today's interesting history editor brings you Sun Wukong why don't you use the golden hoop to support Wuzhishan? Interested readers can follow the details
Today's interesting history editor brings you Wu Song, Yang Guo and Xiao Feng who are more powerful? Interested readers can follow the small details
Do you like the story in Jin Yong ’s story? Today ’s interesting history editor will give you a detailed explanation ~ Jin Yong ’s pen details
Today, the interesting history editor brings you the story of "The Palace of Longevity", and interested readers can follow the editor to take a look at the details
Today, the interesting history editor will bring you who is the monster that Wuwu is afraid of? I hope it will help everyone. In details